We can definitely do something like this. I would just need to come up with some fair criteria that makes this exclusive but still obtainable without it being a gatekeeping thing. There are some people in the community that I feel would be automatically worthy of being on such a list.
Studio now supports a format for exporting and sharing mods. This should help with more people sharing content that can be easily applied to their own servers.
Open to ideas on how to set up the voting/ranking criteria.